![](https://www.sdjewishworld.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Israel-Drazin-130x150.jpg)
PIKESVILLE, Maryland — Since childhood, one of my life guides has been “Always act with a goal in mind.” Later, I saw that Friedrich Nietzsche put the idea this way, “Humans need a goal to live,” and Andrew Carnegie wrote, “If you want to be happy, set a goal that commands your thoughts, liberates your energy and inspires your hopes.” Viktor Frankl developed Logotherapy, a type of psychotherapy that helps people find meaning in their lives and cope with their struggles. While in a Nazi concentration camp as a prisoner, he was able to survive by having as his goal to rejoin his wife.
The film is about the successful attempt to recreate the Jewish State of Israel in 1948. It is fictional based on the superb novel by Leon Uris, also titled Exodus. The name refers to a ship that transported over 600 Jews from Cyprus to Israel, which the British did not want to happen. But it also refers to the movement from slavery to freedom as occurred in the biblical salvation from Egyptian slavery led by Moses, told in the Torah in the book Exodus.
Although fiction, the movie perfectly captures the history and acts of 1948. Its main characters are drawn to show the ideas and feelings of the people in 1948 in Cyprus, where Jews were imprisoned by the British, and Palestine, which Israel was called in 1948. However, they do not have the actual person’s roles then. For example, a man leads Hagenah with ideas like Ben Gorion but is not depicted as Ben Gurion. The same applies to the leader of the Irgun.
We also see a high very active and charismatic fighter in the Hagenah, played by Paul Newman; a non-Jewish nurse who is not inspired by the Jewish need for the return to its homeland but changes her mind; a bigoted British officer who is convinced Jews are so bad you could smell them; a 15-year-old girl who is looking for her dad the only family survivor of the Nazi Holocaust; a young Jewish man who suffered greatly, including sexual abuse by Nazis who wanted, indeed needed, revenge. Also, a British administrator reveals that England promised Jews part of Palestine but now leans toward the Arab desire that Jews should not be in their land; a friendly Arab chief who helps the Jews, and more.
Jews observe a fast day on the Jewish date 9 Av, called in Hebrew Tisha b’Av. It commemorates the destruction of the first temple built by King Solomon and destroyed by the Babylonians in 586 BCE. It also remembers the destruction of the second temple by the Romans in 70 CE. As a result of the later destruction, most Jews have been exiled from their homeland for close to 2000 years, although some always remained home. It should surprise no one that after this long period and the loss of six million Jews murdered by the Nazis during World War Two, exiled Jews wanted to go home in 1948.
Jews go to synagogues on this fast day and mourn the ancient tragedies by reading writings from these days and by prayers.
But is this enough?
I think it is not enough.
Prayer
Just as passive mourning over the loss of the Jewish homeland needs a goal, so too does prayer. Most people think they satisfy the prayer tradition by reciting the words. They do so without searching for what the words teach. They have no goal.
The Hebrew word for “to pray” is lehitpaleil. The root of this word is pll, “judge.” Lehitpalei is reflexive, meaning “judge oneself.” The goal of prayers is to focus on the person reading them, so people should read the prayers and learn to judge themselves.
The Siddur, the daily prayer book, and Machzor, the prayer book for holidays, are not composed to teach a single Jewish concept. The books are a collection of widely different concepts with various ideas, rational, mystic, and many others, from different times from different sources. They are collected not to be read but to understand different views and inspire readers to think, learn, improve, be all they can be, and help all that has been created be what it should be.
Reading prayers without this goal is worthless. God does not need to hear chatter that the chatterer does not understand.
Take the beautiful Friday night prayer Lecha Dodi,” Come, my Beloved,” as an example. Virtually all Jews love the melody and sing along in the synagogue without a goal of understanding what they are singing, believing it is a praise of the Sabbath. This is not true. The song was composed by a mystic during the Middle Ages, reflecting the idea that God is composed of ten parts that became unraveled and will only be restored with the help of humans. And, the mystic contends, only when God is restored will humanity have a messianic age.
Torah and Talmud Study
The same need for a goal applies to Judaism’s significant encouragement of Jews to study the Torah and Talmud. If people do so without the goal of improving themselves and the rest of the world, they are only chattering like birds on a tree. Other birds will find meaning in what they hear, but the Torah reader only hears sounds.
In his book, Tales of Hasidim, Martin Buber tells the story of the great Hasidic Rabbi Zusya (1718-1800). When Zusya was on his deathbed, his students saw he was crying. They tried to comfort him. They told him he was almost as wise as Moses and kind as Abraham. “There is no need to weep. Indeed, you will be judged positively in heaven.” He answered, “When I die and come before the heavenly tribunal, they won’t ask me, ‘Zusya, why weren’t you as wise as Moses or as kind as Abraham,’ instead, they will ask me, ‘Zusya, why weren’t you Zusya?’ Why didn’t I fulfill my potential? Why didn’t I follow the path that could have been mine.”
We can rephrase the response and apply it to ourselves. When we die, God will not ask us how many hours we spent praying and the amount of time we gave to Torah study; He will ask if we set a goal to be all we can be and whether we achieved the goal, helped improve all that I, God, created, and set the stage for the messianic age.
*
Rabbi Dr. Israel Drazin is a retired brigadier general in the U.S. Army Chaplain Corps and the author of more than 50 books.