By Sameea Kamal
CalMatters
SACRAMENTO — Gov. Gavin Newsom said Thursday he supports President Biden’s call for a ceasefire in Gaza, citing the “ongoing and horrific loss of innocent civilian life.”
“I support President Biden’s call for an immediate ceasefire as part of a deal to secure desperately needed relief for Gazan civilians and the release of hostages,” he wrote in a letter addressed to California’s Muslim, Palestinian American, and Arab American communities. “I also unequivocally denounce Hamas’s terrorist attack against Israel. It is time to work in earnest toward an enduring peace that will furnish the lasting security, autonomy, and freedom that the Palestinians and the Israeli people both deserve.”
Newsom’s statement came one day before the U.S. planmed to ask the U.N. Security Council to back a ceasefire resolution, and follows other leaders shifting to more forceful calls for Israel to change its conduct of the war.
On March 3, Vice President Kamala Harris, the former U.S. senator from California, called for an immediate, but temporary ceasefire — the strongest statement from the Biden administration to that point.
Following his State of the Union address on March 7, when he announced a new effort to bring in humanitarian aid by sea, President Biden called for a six-week ceasefire and a hostage-prisoner exchange. And in a call with Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu this week, the president expressed concerns about the civilian death toll and Israel’s blockade of aid delivery, according to a White House summary.
And on March 14, U.S. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, the highest-ranking Jewish elected official, called for new elections in Israel, saying on the Senate floor that Netanyahu is an “obstacle to peace” and “has been too willing to tolerate the civilian toll in Gaza, which is pushing support for Israel worldwide to historic lows.”
The governor’s statement, sent during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, comes after months of criticism by pro-ceasefire supporters that he wasn’t even-handed in his stance on the Gaza war.
But in California, views have been more mixed.
More than 60% of likely voters in California supported an immediate ceasefire in a poll released last month by the Public Policy Institute of California. But they’re more divided on whether to increase, decrease or maintain military aid to Israel and humanitarian aid to Palestinians.
Although the state’s Jewish Democrats have been split over calls for a ceasefire, Newsom’s move puts him at odds with those who have opposed the idea — including U.S. Rep. Adam Schiff, who has advanced to the November election for U.S. Senate. Schiff said earlier this month that a ceasefire must be contingent on Hamas releasing hostages it kidnapped from Israel, and that “the obstacle to getting that temporary ceasefire is Hamas.”
Assembly Republicans have called for a resolution condemning Hamas. And in response to Newsom’s letter, Jim Stanley, Assembly GOP leader James Gallagher’s spokesperson, accused the governor of treating Israeli hostages as “an afterthought.”
In the letter, Newsom acknowledged the suffering of the Muslim community — particularly those who had lost family and friends in Gaza.
“The scale of suffering in Gaza is so vast that it seems few Palestinians across the world have been spared personal loss,” he said. “And now burgeoning disease and starvation threaten to deepen the devastation, especially among children. This is unacceptable.”
Newsom added that he will “always defend your right to take part in the California tradition of peaceful protest — to publicly express your opposition to any war or government decision you oppose, including the war in Gaza.”
Officials from California chapters of the Council on American Islamic Relations and other groups have been pushing the governor for months — including at a meeting in December, where community leaders and organizers from around the state asked the governor to call for a permanent ceasefire.
“We’re pleased to share that after many months of advocacy by various groups, including a meeting CAIR-CA convened with the Governor and Muslim leaders, this afternoon, Governor Newsom joined the resounding global call for ceasefire,” said CAIR California CEO Hussam Ayloush.
The group also praised the governor for sending medical supplies and aid to Gaza.
After the Oct. 7 attack on Israel by the militant group Hamas, in which 1,200 were killed and at least 200 taken hostage, Newsom added a stop in Israel on the way to a climate change tour of China. While in Israel, he met with government officials and visited the parents of a Californian being held hostage. Newsom did not go to Gaza due to security issues, and his pledge of medical and humanitarian aid for Palestinians wasn’t fulfilled until weeks after similar aid was delivered to Israel, also due to security issues.
During a week-long pause in November, Hamas freed more than 100 Israeli and foreign hostages in exchange for Israel releasing about 240 Palestinian prisoners, according to Reuters. Israel’s response to the attack has killed more than 32,000 people, according to Gaza health officials, and displaced 85% of Gaza’s 2.3 million people, according to Human Rights Watch.
In addition to addressing the conflict, Newsom said his administration is focused on battling Islamophobia and anti-Arab hate. Since Oct. 7, Jewish, Arab and Muslim communities around the U.S. have seen increases in incidents of harassment, bias and sometimes physical assault.
Last October, the governor authorized expanding the Nonprofit Security Grant Program, which mosques, churches and synagogues can use to bolster safety and security.
*
Preceding provided by CalMatters, which provides nonprofit, nonpartisan state news
*
San Diego Jewish World addendum: The Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California (JPAC) responded with the following statement on Friday:
“Yesterday, Governor Gavin Newsom published an open letter to California’s Muslim, Palestinian American, and Arab American communities with a much-needed denunciation of Islamophobia and anti-Arab hate. In the letter, Governor Newsom “unequivocally denounce[s] Hamas’s terrorist attack against Israel” and aligns with the Biden administration’s efforts to achieve a six-week humanitarian ceasefire that would return Israeli hostages captured by Hamas and provide aid to Gazan civilians in need. As recently as last week, Israel accepted a framework for this temporary ceasefire. Hamas has rejected this offer.
“The Governor has also made clear numerous times since October 7th that Hamas’ continued rule in Gaza is not compatible with a lasting peace between Israelis and Palestinians. Reflecting on his visit to Israel days after Hamas’ horrific mass murders, he said, “Hamas is a terrorist organization, and they need to be eliminated, not just for the people of Israel and Jews around the world, but for the Palestinians themselves.” Again earlier this month, the Governor stressed that he wants “Hamas eliminated.”
“In response to the letter, we have been in close communication with the Governor and his team, and we appreciate his support for JPAC’s core positions on the Israel-Hamas war: 1) returning all remaining hostages to Israel, 2) removing Hamas from military control, 3) maximizing humanitarian aid to Gazans, and 4) minimizing civilian casualties. We look forward to continuing our close working relationship with Governor Newsom to strengthen California-Israel ties, achieve a peaceful and secure future for both Israelis and Palestinians, counter antisemitism, and make California a safe and welcoming place for all. “