Published by
AFP
AFP
Washington (AFP) – A long-awaited State Department report on Friday said that Israel likely violated norms on international law in its use of US weapons but it did not find enough evidence to block shipments. The report said it was “reasonable to assess” that Israel, which receives some $3 billion in US weapons a year, has used the arms in ways inconsistent with standards on humanitarian rights but that the United States could not reach “conclusive findings.” The report had been held up for several days amid debate within the State Department on whether to reprimand Israel, a historic US ally …
The following e-mailed comments were received by San Diego Jewish World which I as editor pass along in the interest of presenting a range of Jewish opinion:
REACTIONS:
Sen. Ben Cardin, chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee:
“The U.S. has shown a clear commitment to ensuring Israel has what it needs to defend itself against ongoing threats posed by Hamas, Iran, and terrorist networks in the region. America’s action has always been guided by our national security interests of pursuing two states for two peoples, where Israelis and Palestinians live side by side in peace, security, dignity, and mutual recognition. Today’s vote in the UN General Assembly only threatens this path to a durable peace.
“It is critical for the international community to remain focused on who perpetrated the Oct 7th massacre – Hamas. Rather than negotiating in good faith, Hamas is playing games with a reasonable agreement to release innocent hostages and bring about an extended ceasefire, further proof that there is no peaceful future for Israelis or Palestinians if Hamas is able to operate in Gaza.
“Israel has a right to target Hamas leadership in Gaza, but there is a right way to pursue that goal. Going into Rafah without a credible plan to deal with the humanitarian situation is not the right way.
“Any operation must take all measures to protect civilian lives. There must be safe passage for innocent civilians currently displaced inside Rafah. They need to have the necessary food, water, shelter, medical care, and all other humanitarian provisions. It is in the interest of Israel and the US that there be sustained, effective humanitarian assistance available to those at risk in Gaza, and it needs to be provided without delay or interruption.
“Pressuring Hamas should not be limited to military means. Arab countries have a leadership role to play in offering Palestinians positive alternatives and steering public opinion away from Hamas.
“While the most recent report regarding Israel under the NSM-20 has raised concerns, I agree with its assessment that Israel has not violated International Humanitarian Law and that military assistance to support Israel’s security remains in the U.S. interest and should continue. In this regard, I differ with President Biden’s recent decision.”